I would rate them a 6.5/10, as they have some creasing (pics taken unstuffed), some wear on soles (still firm), scuffs/marks on the uppers (mainly at the areas near the tassels, but also in a few other areas throughout). These have been conditioned with Saphir Renovateur, and have a beautiful sheen with no signs of cracking anywhere.They are marked a size 9.5 D, which is a normal width. These look great overall and will be a stunning addition to any man's closet. Any questions, please contact me. The item "RARE Hanover Shell Cordovan 9.5 D Black Tassel Loafer Shoes Mens Vintage Slip On" is in sale since Saturday, March 7, 2020. This item is in the category "Clothing, Shoes & Accessories\Men\Men's Shoes\Dress Shoes". The seller is "the-finer_things" and is located in Minneapolis, Minnesota. This item can be shipped to United States.